"They didn't skimp!" That was the most-used phrase during our stay!
This was their opening weekend, & Karen & her husband have created a resort-like feel in a cozy spot right by Lake Erie...heated pool, hot tub, waterfall, plentiful pool deck, chairs with cushions, many places to sit & read or eat outside, lots of pool floats, kayaks you can use on the lake, a swing right by the lake with access to the water, & that's just the outside!
Inside, things were well-designed to be functional, comfortable, & luxurious! Lots of windows, soft/thick beach & bath towels...& so many of them for just the two of us! The bed was so comfy, the linens were so soft, & the pillows were perfect. & I'm super picky!
The kitchen was well-stocked with all we needed. I usually notice a bunch of things that could be better when I stay somewhere, & one reason we could relax so well there was that we didn't see anything to improve. They already made it so much nicer than we could have imagined!

Karen was beyond amazing & communicative from day one, as well as while we were on the property. The cottage was spotless & absolutely gorgeous. We felt right at home & we cannot wait to return.

We really enjoyed our stay here. The inn is across the street from the lake but you still get a great view. We stayed in the Seagull Serenity room, 2nd floor of the main inn. The room was clean, cozy, & well stocked for our stay. The premises also have a pool & a hot tub in addition to a short walking trail behind the property. There is a swing lakeside along with kayaks if you want to adventure out onto the lake. The 2nd floor balcony is a great place to watch the sunset over the lake. Our property hostess was very attentive to our needs. Our room had a queen sized bed, kitchen area, & shower area. It provided all we needed for a short stay. It is also close to the island ferry & some good restaurants, a brewery, & winery.

Had the best time here for a weekend staycation! The place is absolutely beautiful. It’s everything you could want & more!
It is conveniently located by ferries for Put-In-Bay & Kelly’s Island. There are kayaks to use in the private part of the lake. The pool has a bunch of rafts & pool toys. Each cottage is supplied with board games. There’s no way you can get bored here!

Great place to stay. Atmosphere, location, accommodations, amenities, all top notch. We had a terrific weekend stay & would definitely return.

I stayed here for a couple nights & had the best experience! The rooms are so comfortable, clean, & made me feel right at home. I love the convenience of the washer & dryer in the suite & my own kitchen. The pool & hot tub were just steps outside of my room & I thoroughly enjoyed them throughout the weekend. The inn even provides kayaks to use in the lake right across the street! The location is very convenient, close to everything Catawba has to offer, & is near ferries to other islands like Put-In-Bay. Views of the sunset & lake are incredible from the inn. I highly recommend staying here!

We really liked the Catawba Stone Inn. It was super clean & our unit had everything you need to really enjoy your stay. We really enjoyed the built in pool. The staff kept the pool clean. Just steps away we enjoyed beautiful sunsets on the lake.

I had a great time at the Catawba Stone Inn. The property is quaint with historic charm but has been renovated & feels modern, clean, & convenient. The rooms & cottages are the perfect place to relax & unwind on the beautiful Lake Erie coast but the Inn is close to Cedar Point, the islands, Marblehead, & many fantastic restaurants. The staff went out of their way to welcome me & my husband & made sure I had the best stay possible!

This was an ideal spot for a weekend getaway for our small family. Property is beautiful & well maintained. Awesome clean pool, easy access to the lake, & amazing scenery. Owners were very accommodating & really care about your experience. Also centrally located between all of the local attractions. We’ll be back!